With the near-impossible task of avoiding generative AI and other open-source AI tools, what will the effect be upon our academic institutions going forward? Will they circumvent the current systems, or will universities lead the way where learning is revolutionised?
Since the New Labour government of Blair & Brown, and the 2008 housing market crash, it can be argued that the value of a degree has depleted over the years. The availability of further education available to the millennials of the time was unprecedented. The previous generations had enjoyed affordable mortgages with the right to buy schemes, protection of the trade unions, and a generation of no severe or global wars.
Generation X and millennials took full advantage of these opportunities, entering adulthood with confidence and optimism. Many assumed that affordable housing and widely accessible higher education would continue indefinitely. Growing up before the dominance of social media and reality television, they compared their lives only with those in their immediate surroundings, fostering a more grounded sense of expectation.
To their surprise, once they emerged from their adolescent cocoons, they found the world wanting. Blair’s government encouraged such a high number of university entries; local trade-based colleges known as polytechnics had to pick up the slack. This left a generation of students graduating with degrees that had no real-world application and, depending on their establishment, little value academically. The new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has expressed his feelings on Labour’s previous education initiatives, stating, “hard-hats are as important as graduate caps.” And the bomb of the housing market crash of ‘08 had a generational crisis written on its shell, leading to a lack of housing, unaffordable rents for students and homeownership a far-off dream.
In the 18 years since this country has gone through an independence referendum, Brexit, Covid-19, and the ongoing effects of the invasion of Ukraine and Palestine (or Gaza, depending on viewpoint). So, it is fair to say times are tough. But with the introduction of smartphones, social media, and unlimited access to information, there are emerging technologies making students’ lives easier.
So, as the first few weeks as a first-year student go by, you cannot help but notice the importance of the AI etiquette deliberated, and a slight worry in the eyes of academics. They highlight the importance of learning the skills of analysis and comparison and that the use of AI directly undermines this. And with all departments having a different policy outlined on its use, it is clear there is an attempt to keep up with the fast-growing technology, albeit a varied one. But with government regulation unable to keep pace, academia may need to revolutionise on its own merit.
Dr John Moravec, an educational futurist consultant, has stated, “We often hear that AI will democratize education. It’s a comforting idea: that machine learning can help level the playing field, offering personalised learning at scale, freeing up faculty time, and making education more accessible. But democratisation implies equal power—and AI systems don’t operate in neutral terrain. Somebody always owns the tool we use. Thus, it is important to keep in mind that democratisation does not always equal democracy.”
This is a reminder that AI technologies, however useful they are or may prove to be, that at some point they may not be free at the point of use. They may not be as available in the real world as they are now, and this underlines the importance of using your time at university to learn the adequate skills being taught. And with the likely future costs of these AI products and tools, the cultural capital scales we have spent generations trying to balance may be about to emulate the wealth gap currently experienced in the world.
An all-out ban may be the greater way to communicate the use of AI, with unapproved use leading to academic intervention or even expulsion. At least until the technology is actualised and a clear policy across all departments or universities can be implemented. But for now, we remain in the grey.


Leave a Reply